Are Pizza Boxes Recyclable?—A Q&A with the Oneida

Digital Content Manager

UTICA, N.Y. (WKTV) -- What burning questions have you had about your recyclables?

The Oneida-Herkimer Solid Waste Authority, also known as The Authority, regularly receives a bunch of questions about the recycling process.

The Authority has taken note of those questions and has put together a list of common questions paired their answers.

Like, for example, a pretty popular question: Are pizza boxes recyclable?

"This is something that we leave up to residents’ discretion," The Authority stated. "If the box has a lot of grease or cheese stuck to it, then it would be better to put it in the garbage. Otherwise, it can be recycled."

Or, here's one that's very specific.

What is the difference between a wet strength box and a carton?

According to The Authority, "A wet strength box is any kind of box that goes in your refrigerator or freezer like soda can or popsicle boxes, for example. Wet strength boxes have a chemical in them that keep them from breaking down in case they get wet. This chemical cannot be removed from the paper fibers that make up the box, therefore wet strength boxes are not recyclable. Cartons, on the other hand, are recyclable. This is because instead of having a chemical mixed with the paper fibers to help protect them, the paper fibers have a protective waxy coating that can be removed at recycling mills."

And the answer to the age-old question: Does it matter if plastic bottles or glass jars have their lids/caps on?

"When you are recycling plastic bottles and glass jars, you can rinse them out and put the lids right back on them. The plastic and metal lids are recyclable but may not be recovered for recycling if they are not in their original container," The Authority answered.

Here's another popular one.

"How much plastic is actually recycled? I heard most plastic doesn’t get recycled, and a lot of it ends up in the landfill."

The Authority answered this question by stating that it has one of the most comprehensive recycling systems in the state.

"We accept the items that we do (whether it is plastic or another material) because we have an outlet for that material to be recycled. It would be a waste of money, time and energy to advertise that we accept plastic for recycling, just to only collect a few types and send the rest to the landfill. Of the plastic that comes to the recycling center, about 10% is landfilled because of contamination from “wishcycling” (or, putting items in the recycling bin hoping that it will be recycled), dirty recyclables, and lack of education. We have one of the largest accepted lists in the state due to our single stream processing system and therefore can accept more types of the many kinds of plastic than our surrounding counties. In 2022, we marketed 2,070 tons, or 4,140,000 pounds of plastic for recycling," The Authority continued.

Have you ever wondered why your garbage and recyclables go into the same truck?

"Some waste haulers use split body trucks. In these trucks, they can collect garbage and recyclables at the same time, helping cut down on the time it takes for them to complete a collection route. When they arrive at our facilities, the garbage side of the truck is emptied in the transfer station and the recycling side of the truck is emptied in the recycling center. If you have any issues with how your waste is being collected, you can contact your waste hauler directly so they can address the issue. City of Utica residents can contact the Authority’s Utica Coordinator at (315) 731-0238 with any waste collection issues," The Authority said.

One of the last questions that's addressed is one about paint.

"Where can I get rid of paint when the Authority’s HHW facility is closed?"

The Authority said that "paint is now accepted for recycling at participating retailers through a program called PaintCare. PaintCare is a program of the American Coatings Association and was established in New York State in 2022. When you buy paint, there is now a small added fee, which helps fund the PaintCare program. Paint that is recycled through this program is either reused or processed into fuel. More information about PaintCare can be found here: https://www.paintcare.org/states/new-york/."

Have more questions? You can contact The Authority at 315-733-1224 or [email protected].

If you have story ideas, please send them to [email protected].

Digital Content Manager